Home View Postings Leave A Posting About Us Mission Statement Academic Freedom FAQ Help Us Rebuttals In The News Related Articles Archives Terms of Service Privacy Policy Contact Us



[links]

[Help NoIndoctrination.org - Donate Now Through Network For Good]
[NoIndoctrination.org]
News Flash from NoIndoctrination.org

Click here to read the Academic Freedom Discourse between the University of California and NoIndoctrination.org.

Students' Academic Freedom Rights Will Be Undermined by UC Proposal
Please Read and Act

After reading, click here to see how you can help!

University of California President Richard Atkinson and UC Berkeley Law School Professor Robert Post are proposing a new statement on Academic Freedom for the University of California - one that NoIndoctrination.org believes will undermine the academic freedom rights of students. President Atkinson claims that the current statement is "outdated": "I believe the University's stance on academic freedom should reflect the modern university and its faculty."(1) NoIndoctrination.org finds no justification for the proposed changes.

The following statements are part of the current UC document on Academic Freedom, but these will be eliminated if the Atkinson/Post proposal is adopted:

  • "To convert, or to make converts, is alien and hostile to this dispassionate duty. Where it becomes necessary, in performing this function of a university, to consider political, social, or sectarian movements, they are dissected and examined - not taught, and the conclusion left, with no tipping of the scales, to the logic of the facts."

  • "Essentially the freedom of a university is the freedom of competent persons in the classroom. In order to protect this freedom, the University assumes the right to prevent exploitation of its prestige by unqualified persons or by those who would use it as a platform for propaganda."

  • "Its high function - and its high privilege, the University will steadily continue to fulfill, serving the people by providing facilities for investigation and teaching free from domination by parties, sects, or selfish interests."

The proposal claims that APM-015 (the UC Faculty Code of Conduct)(2) covers such issues. While APM-015 does have a few statements that protect students' rights, it is extremely limited, and NoIndoctrination.org finds in them no adequate replacement for the statements quoted above. As far as the academic freedom rights of students are concerned, the new proposal eliminates everything of substance. Just when NoIndoctrination.org is mounting a campaign to insist that UC honors its proclamations about academic freedom and responsibility, President Atkinson has decided it is time to change the ground rules.

Apparently Atkinson and Post find it "outdated" for modern faculty members to avoid using their courses as "stages for propaganda." Apparently they see no reason why modern faculty should provide a balanced view when discussing political and social movements. Apparently they see no reason why modern faculty should provide teaching "free from domination by parties, sects, or selfish interests."

Weakening the University of California's statement on Academic Freedom will only serve to perpetuate the kinds of abuses documented on NoIndoctrination.org.

Luann Wright
President and Founder
NoIndoctrination.org

References:

1. UC President Atkinson's letter justifying the proposal, the current and proposed UC Academic Freedom statements as well as other university statements (http://www.universityofcalifornia.edu/senate/assembly/may2003/may2003viia6.pdf)

2. UC Faculty Code of Conduct (http://www.ucop.edu/acadadv/acadpers/apm/apm-015.pdf)


WHAT YOU CAN DO TO HELP
(Anyone can help, not just Californians!)

Concerned citizens (students, parents, taxpayers, academics) may register their opinion on this proposed change with the UC Regents c/o the Secretary of the Regents Leigh Trivette (leigh.trivette@ucop.edu) and with the UC Academic Council Chair Gayle Binion (gayle.binion@ucop.edu) and Vice Chair Lawrence Pitts (lawrence.pitts@ucop.edu). These individuals are not accustomed to hearing from the public; therefore, your emails or letters can have a significant impact! Feel free to forward this message on to others who may share our concerns about the eroding rights of students and the increasing toleration of classroom abuse.




The opinions expressed within NoIndoctrination.org are not necessarily those held by NoIndoctrination.org
Copyright © 2002-07, NoIndoctrination.org